1916 · CLOSE READING
A Prophet In His Own Country
A Prophet In His Own Country (1916), PDF p. 11
Original page
Enlarge ↗
Highlights use the original PDF text layer. OCR-only matches may not be visible on the scan.
Transcription
Download text ↓raw extractionoriginal embedded textReview: unreviewed
comment in various places upon these letters. It is
also to be remarked how curious a form Mr. Stuart
has chosen for the expression of his thoughts. It is
simple, attractive, and convenient, and possesses the
great advantage that his messages are automatically
dated.
Mr. G. K. Chesterton, in one of his books, I
think that on Browning, has remarked upon the utter
futility of language. It is impossible to express
thought, unless the person who is to receive it has
already some inkling of what is meant. For
example, if I say that someone is a Puritan, the
remark may be taken as a complement or as an
insult, according to the ideas in the mind of the
reader, or of his ideas as to what my ideas may be.
Unless the context makes it clear, doubt is certain to
remain. Nor need one suppose that there are any
words free from this ambiguity. Everything at one
time or another has been the subject of violent
praise and violent blame. If any one asks me for the
meaning of the word God, I must first know
whether the word is being used by the Pope or Mr.
G. W. Foote or Herbert Spencer or Billy Sunday. If
you ask me for the meaning of the word soul, I
am equally at a loss. To the Buddhist it is a figment
of the imagination of certain Hindu philosophers.
The Qabalists use it as almost synonymous with
body. Every metaphysician that ever lived has
used this word in a different sense, and has nearly
always forgotten to define it. Now if, to bring back
the matter to the question of Mr. Stuart and his
letters to the universe, we find in one of them the
word gold, we may be too ready to assume that
Page provenance & review flags
Stable page ID: b8003285752571b0f21f86fb:p00011
Line breaks are preserved. Reading order and OCR accuracy may need review.
Printed page label has not been verified.
- No automated review flags. This does not establish transcription accuracy.